|
Post by Philcounty on Nov 27, 2023 21:37:01 GMT
Al Hamadi is playing in a poorer team and has played 3 games less than Tanto due to international duty (also only one more than Barry). He's achieving very respectable stats considering. Goals + Assists Tanto - 14 Al Hamadi - 13 Barry - 11 Minutes per goal/Goals per game Tanto - 117/0.77 Al Hamadi - 168/0.54 Shot accuracy Tanto - 77% Al Hamadi - 64% Conversion rate Tanto - 46% Al Hamadi - 21% He shoots more and has a few assists more than Tanto; every other metric of a striker, Tanto is head and shoulders past him. Not like anyone here has seen Al Hamadi play 90 minutes this season to judge it either. He might go on to be great and I'm not saying he isn't, but let's not go overboard and undervalue Tanto's contribution. Nothing says to me that this bloke's better. I'm not saying he's better but he's a very good player hence the seven figure offers for him. He has scored more goals for Wimbledon since joining in January than Tanto has since joining us at around the same time. He's probably had more minutes in that time but goals scored (and this season the assists he's added) are the stats that are getting him noticed.
|
|
|
Post by Nik on Nov 27, 2023 21:55:21 GMT
Minutes per goal/Goals per game Tanto - 117/0.77 Al Hamadi - 168/0.54 Shot accuracy Tanto - 77% Al Hamadi - 64% Conversion rate Tanto - 46% Al Hamadi - 21% He shoots more and has a few assists more than Tanto; every other metric of a striker, Tanto is head and shoulders past him. Not like anyone here has seen Al Hamadi play 90 minutes this season to judge it either. He might go on to be great and I'm not saying he isn't, but let's not go overboard and undervalue Tanto's contribution. Nothing says to me that this bloke's better. I'm not saying he's better but he's a very good player hence the seven figure offers for him. He has scored more goals for Wimbledon since joining in January than Tanto has since joining us at around the same time. He's probably had more minutes in that time but goals scored (and this season the assists he's added) are the stats that are getting him noticed. You didn't but earlier in the thread it was said that he was overall better than Tanto. The stats don't back that up and, alternatively, nobody here's seen the guy play 90 minutes this season to make a non-stats-based judgement like that.
|
|
|
Post by Philcounty on Nov 27, 2023 22:00:37 GMT
I'm not saying he's better but he's a very good player hence the seven figure offers for him. He has scored more goals for Wimbledon since joining in January than Tanto has since joining us at around the same time. He's probably had more minutes in that time but goals scored (and this season the assists he's added) are the stats that are getting him noticed. You didn't but earlier in the thread it was said that he was overall better than Tanto. The stats don't back that up and, alternatively, nobody here's seen the guy play 90 minutes this season to make a non-stats-based judgement like that. Ah OK, I didn't see that part.
|
|
|
Post by mat1scfc on Nov 28, 2023 11:35:05 GMT
Wrexham being linked with saidou khan in January from Swindon apparently for 350k
Yes it's from footy insider who is very 50/50 if not more than 50 in the shit (don't know if that makes sense) but if it's true that's stupid money for someone when they paid a fee for a cdm in the summer from millwall
|
|
|
Post by houldsworthhatter on Nov 28, 2023 12:21:14 GMT
Wrexham being linked with saidou khan in January from Swindon apparently for 350k Yes it's from footy insider who is very 50/50 if not more than 50 in the shit (don't know if that makes sense) but if it's true that's stupid money for someone when they paid a fee for a cdm in the summer from millwall A midfielder. Mr Khan will have whiplash standing watching the ball fly over his head for 90 plus minutes at a time.
|
|
|
Post by alkringtonhatter on Nov 28, 2023 21:50:35 GMT
Jesus, 350K for someone who didnβt look outstanding for Chesterfield in the conference? Maybe the Wrexham tax is real, or maybe his agent is stirring.
Btw someone tell Swindon to calm down. Up to 7th, 4-0 up at Accy in stoppage time and win⦠4-3.
|
|
|
Post by slomasscfc on Nov 29, 2023 9:56:06 GMT
Puskas award wrapped up πππ
|
|
|
Post by bristolhatter on Nov 29, 2023 10:04:32 GMT
Puskas award wrapped up πππ It was Drysdale (the same ref we had Saturday), also allowed Tanto's last minute goal despite protests of foul on the keeper. Good to see he's not falling for the dramatic keeper theatrics but wish he'd practiced what he preaches and not gone down like a fanny when he got in Powell's way lol
|
|
|
Post by slomasscfc on Nov 29, 2023 10:11:52 GMT
Puskas award wrapped up πππ It was Drysdale (the same ref we had Saturday), also allowed Tanto's last minute goal despite protests of foul on the keeper. Good to see he's not falling for the dramatic keeper theatrics but wish he'd practiced what he preaches and not gone down like a fanny when he got in Powell's way lol I mean it's still a foul by Cosgrove on keeper that he has ball in his hands and he deliberately runs into him, but almost deserves to be allowed as no way it makes keeper fall like that and why he not held onto ball π If I'm manager I'm tearing strips off him in changing room long midweek away trip to do that in last min, what's he doing lots different ways he could gone about it just pick ball up stay out trouble and hoof it down field as far out of play as possible
|
|
|
Post by Philcounty on Dec 1, 2023 20:13:03 GMT
Will be a big blow for them if he is out for a while. They've not been conceding as much since he's been in.
|
|
|
Post by Fallowfield Hatter on Dec 1, 2023 20:38:23 GMT
Will be a big blow for them if he is out for a while. They've not been conceding as much since he's been in.
|
|
|
Post by Stranded Hatter on Dec 1, 2023 21:48:59 GMT
Will be a big blow for them if he is out for a while. They've not been conceding as much since he's been in. I know he's done well for them but their fans seem convinced he's the best keeper in the division by miles, when he played against us for Crewe last year I thought he was awful and was stunned when he got a loan out in Europe. I think it's more they've had so many awful keepers for so long that he stands out as being pretty good for the level.
|
|
|
Post by Philcounty on Dec 1, 2023 21:56:32 GMT
Will be a big blow for them if he is out for a while. They've not been conceding as much since he's been in. I know he's done well for them but their fans seem convinced he's the best keeper in the division by miles, when he played against us for Crewe last year I thought he was awful and was stunned when he got a loan out in Europe. I think it's more they've had so many awful keepers for so long that he stands out as being pretty good for the level. I think we caught him on a bad day last Boxing Day. He was very highly thought of by a lot of people last season. I believe he has the 3rd highest save % of all the keepers in the top 4 divisions this season which isn't something to be sniffed at. He's capable of the odd eccentric moment but I don't think that's surprising considering he's only 21. He might not be the best keeper in L2 (although he must be close) but he definitely has the potential to go a lot higher than anyone else at this level, I think.
|
|
|
Post by houldsworthhatter on Dec 1, 2023 22:01:27 GMT
Will be a big blow for them if he is out for a while. They've not been conceding as much since he's been in. I know he's done well for them but their fans seem convinced he's the best keeper in the division by miles, when he played against us for Crewe last year I thought he was awful and was stunned when he got a loan out in Europe. I think it's more they've had so many awful keepers for so long that he stands out as being pretty good for the level. Did you also see his utter cock up in their defeat at Accrington? Comedy gold before Rat Face upstaged him with the penalty miss π€£π€£
|
|
|
Post by timberwolf on Dec 2, 2023 8:30:33 GMT
I know he's done well for them but their fans seem convinced he's the best keeper in the division by miles, when he played against us for Crewe last year I thought he was awful and was stunned when he got a loan out in Europe. I think it's more they've had so many awful keepers for so long that he stands out as being pretty good for the level. Did you also see his utter cock up in their defeat at Accrington? Comedy gold before Rat Face upstaged him with the penalty miss π€£π€£ Not awful keepers but ones that vary from game to game with no middle ground. Bad one week MOTM contenders the next. Was actually surprised at the performance of the salford keeper last tuesday night as he is another with big mistakes in him. Ben might makes the odd he should have done better moments but overall there is not a great difference between his top game and his poor one which for me is what goalkeeping is all about.
|
|