Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Aug 27, 2023 9:19:22 GMT
I think loaning out Joe Lewis was a mistake
|
|
|
|
Post by AllyF on Aug 27, 2023 9:23:07 GMT
I think loaning out Joe Lewis was a mistake Loaning him out to the team our DOF himself considered the division's dark horses was puzzling in the extreme after what happened with Barclay last season |
|
|
|
Post by Gary_1883 on Aug 27, 2023 9:30:54 GMT
I think loaning out Joe Lewis was a mistake Loaning him out to the team our DOF himself considered the division's dark horses was puzzling in the extreme after what happened with Barclay last season Sign him. Don't play him. Extend his contract. Send him to play for a division rival. Is this one of the slides on Wilson's super-clever recruitment strategy? |
|
|
|
Post by vicar on Aug 27, 2023 10:05:25 GMT
We already know there's players coming in this week and maybe a couple leaving Who do think will leave? Crankshaw? Sarce? I'd be disappointed to see Sarce go but times up for Crankshaw and Evans IMO, I certainly think Challinor has enough credit in the bank to be given until Christmas. |
|
|
|
Post by atmosphere on Aug 27, 2023 10:10:32 GMT
I actually agree with Matt on Sarcevic. Wouldn't be disappointed if he went this week. His injury record is bad and getting worse and worse. One year left this will be his last final season anyway.
|
|
|
|
Post by The Real Exile on Aug 27, 2023 10:48:01 GMT
I think loaning out Joe Lewis was a mistake Not unless we were going with a 4. |
|
|
|
Post by mat1scfc on Aug 27, 2023 10:51:00 GMT
I actually agree with Matt on Sarcevic. Wouldn't be disappointed if he went this week. His injury record is bad and getting worse and worse. One year left this will be his last final season anyway. I know some rate sarcevic quite highly in our squad and fair enough people have different opinions but he's just too slow and injurys have certainly caught up to him. A few people on here said it last before the season ended last season and I agreed we should've gone for Dan kemp. He's an attacking midfielder who can also play on the wing. He knows how's to score as he scored 9 goals in 16 games for Hartlepool last season. This season he's scored 4 goals and got 3 assist in 4 games. He's only 24 too and I'm really unsure why mk dons aren't using him as he's at Swindon on loan. |
|
|
|
Post by scfc73 on Aug 27, 2023 11:23:19 GMT
Loaning him out to the team our DOF himself considered the division's dark horses was puzzling in the extreme after what happened with Barclay last season Sign him. Don't play him. Extend his contract. Send him to play for a division rival. Is this one of the slides on Wilson's super-clever recruitment strategy? I agree it's a weird strategy for a club that has set itself a target of rapid progression. Same as the Chadwick signing, we need a striker so we signed a player who may or may not be any good, injury affected, from a higher division, but then loan him out immediately to a side a division below us & 3 divisions below where he came from. This may be termed as 'player development' but in no way is it helping our immediate cause which is promotion, & as suedehead has rightly stated in the Mansfield thread that target has been set by the club & owner not the fans so IMO the club should make acquisitions that benefit us in that immediate cause & not be pissing about with players who may or may not come good. |
|
|
|
Post by timberwolf on Aug 27, 2023 11:23:45 GMT
I actually agree with Matt on Sarcevic. Wouldn't be disappointed if he went this week. His injury record is bad and getting worse and worse. One year left this will be his last final season anyway. I know some rate sarcevic quite highly in our squad and fair enough people have different opinions but he's just too slow and injurys have certainly caught up to him. A few people on here said it last before the season ended last season and I agreed we should've gone for Dan kemp. He's an attacking midfielder who can also play on the wing. He knows how's to score as he scored 9 goals in 16 games for Hartlepool last season. This season he's scored 4 goals and got 3 assist in 4 games. He's only 24 too and I'm really unsure why mk dons aren't using him as he's at Swindon on loan. A fit sarc on his game would benefit the team as he has done in the past. Just wonder looking at dan kemp that mkdons and County have something in common. Not getting the best out of players they have. |
|
|
|
Post by timberwolf on Aug 27, 2023 11:30:12 GMT
I agree it's a weird strategy for a club that has set itself a target of rapid progression. Same as the Chadwick signing, we need a striker so we signed a player who may or may not be any good, injury affected, from a higher division, but then loan him out immediately to a side a division below us & 3 divisions below where he came from. This may be termed as 'player development' but in no way is it helping our immediate cause which is promotion, & as suedehead has rightly stated in the Mansfield thread that target has been set by the club & owner not the fans so IMO the club should make acquisitions that benefit us in that immediate cause & not be pissing about with players who may or may not come good. The loaning out of pye and johnson is far different to the chadwick situation especially if their ages are taken into account. Why did we also sign that lad from ireland who has gone back there who no fan ever saw. Think we have signed more players to make an impact from day one but have failed to do so by not playing them as their previous clubs did where they made an impact. |
|
|
|
Post by timberwolf on Aug 27, 2023 11:47:04 GMT
So far there are 6 of us wanting rid of him this week. Talk about him not having a plan B, just wonder what plan B those 6 have.
|
|
|
|
Post by David Schofield on Aug 27, 2023 12:18:59 GMT
So far there are 6 of us wanting rid of him this week. Talk about him not having a plan B, just wonder what plan B those 6 have. If we want a Director of Football to run the football operation and just want a Coach to get a tune out of the players in the pitch (which was clearly the plan with Rusk’s appointment) then Pete Wild would be a great choice - highly skilled coach and a good motivator with the knowledge and experience of lower league football If we want the full package then Leam Richardson would be my choice However, I’m in the leave DC to get on with it camp - it’s the structure above that isn’t working |
|
|
|
Post by vicar on Aug 27, 2023 12:34:05 GMT
Sign him. Don't play him. Extend his contract. Send him to play for a division rival. Is this one of the slides on Wilson's super-clever recruitment strategy? I agree it's a weird strategy for a club that has set itself a target of rapid progression. Same as the Chadwick signing, we need a striker so we signed a player who may or may not be any good, injury affected, from a higher division, but then loan him out immediately to a side a division below us & 3 divisions below where he came from. This may be termed as 'player development' but in no way is it helping our immediate cause which is promotion, & as suedehead has rightly stated in the Mansfield thread that target has been set by the club & owner not the fans so IMO the club should make acquisitions that benefit us in that immediate cause & not be pissing about with players who may or may not come good. I don't think there's a lot wrong with the Chadwick signing, he was highly rated at Hull and he's got a year to prove his fitness and to show what he has to offer, he's not part of the rapid promotion plan but part of the medium to long term strategy, if he doesn't work out we'll let him go but he doesn't make much of a difference to what's happening this season. |
|
|
|
Post by mat1scfc on Aug 27, 2023 12:42:59 GMT
I agree it's a weird strategy for a club that has set itself a target of rapid progression. Same as the Chadwick signing, we need a striker so we signed a player who may or may not be any good, injury affected, from a higher division, but then loan him out immediately to a side a division below us & 3 divisions below where he came from. This may be termed as 'player development' but in no way is it helping our immediate cause which is promotion, & as suedehead has rightly stated in the Mansfield thread that target has been set by the club & owner not the fans so IMO the club should make acquisitions that benefit us in that immediate cause & not be pissing about with players who may or may not come good. I don't think there's a lot wrong with the Chadwick signing, he was highly rated at Hull and he's got a year to prove his fitness and to show what he has to offer, he's not part of the rapid promotion plan but part of the medium to long term strategy, if he doesn't work out we'll let him go but he doesn't make much of a difference to what's happening this season. don't think he's scored for gatehead in 5 games for them but he's not 100% fit because he got injured while with us and was recovering with gatehead and only get sub appearances |
|
|
|
Post by vicar on Aug 27, 2023 13:00:20 GMT
I don't think there's a lot wrong with the Chadwick signing, he was highly rated at Hull and he's got a year to prove his fitness and to show what he has to offer, he's not part of the rapid promotion plan but part of the medium to long term strategy, if he doesn't work out we'll let him go but he doesn't make much of a difference to what's happening this season. don't think he's scored for gatehead in 5 games for them but he's not 100% fit because he got injured while with us and was recovering with gatehead and only get sub appearances As I said he's got the season to prove himself. |
|
